Status complete (120 trees, all fitted); superseded by E46 (recovery) and E47 (selection) when they report (Estimability)
Package build the build audit puts the libraries of E18-E23 at edce33d … f5bf6f1, identical to clean builds; the centred models are in emphasis main from edce33d
Driver / analysis sim/E18-centred.R; figures fig-centred, fig-s-nedc-recovery
Data results/E18/centred.csv (120 rows)

Question

Fair-proportion ED is not centred: \(\mathrm{ED}_s = \overline{\mathrm{ED}} + e_s\), and the clade mean \(\overline{\mathrm{ED}} = \mathrm{PD}/N\) is a clade-level quantity that \(N\) already tracks. \(D\) is centred by construction; ED is not. On Icteridae (E5) ed alone loses to dd while ned beats both by 15-17 AIC. The hypothesis: \(\beta_{ED}\) pays two AIC units to carry a component \(N\) already carries, so a centred covariate \(\mathrm{ED}^*_s = \mathrm{ED}_s - \mathrm{PD}/N\) (package models edc, nedc) would make the same contrast selectable where E12 found selection at -0.15\(\lambda\) of only 0.05-0.55.

Design

parameter value meaning
generators ned (raw ED) and nedc (centred ED) the same \(\beta_{ED}\), so the per-lineage contrast is identical and only the clade-level shift differs
ED effect 0, -0.15, -0.35 \(\lambda\) linear link
tips, turnover 100, 0.10 \(K\) recalibrated per generator
trees per cell 20 6 cells, 120 trees
candidates dd, ned, nedc every tree fitted with all three
draws, iterations, clock 600, max_iter 100, 50 minutes (3000 s)
proposal, box surrogate; sim/box.R under the centred covariate the surrogate's mean-field lineage has \(\mathrm{ED}^* = 0\), so its rate is the dd rate

Pre-set rule

00-design.md §E18: selection at -0.15\(\lambda\) rising from E12's 0.05-0.55 to \(\ge 0.5\) under the centred fit, with \(\hat\beta_{ED^*}\) recovered no worse than \(\hat\beta_{ED}\). If it does not move, the difficulty is power and not parametrisation, and the centred form is reported as an equivalent choice rather than a better one.

Results

generated effect fit ratio (q1-q3) sign median ESS of 600 fits < 10 over dd by > 2 AIC stops conv/cap/clock
ned -0.35\(\lambda\) ned 1.00 (0.82-1.13) 1.00 40.0 3 0.75 0/1/19
ned -0.35\(\lambda\) nedc 0.88 (0.74-1.11) 1.00 41.2 4 0.75 0/5/15
nedc -0.35\(\lambda\) ned 1.03 (0.84-1.20) 1.00 33.5 1 0.80 0/1/19
nedc -0.35\(\lambda\) nedc 0.98 (0.85-1.13) 1.00 41.4 2 0.90 0/3/17
ned -0.15\(\lambda\) ned 1.20 (0.81-1.51) 0.90 63.9 2 0.05 0/2/18
ned -0.15\(\lambda\) nedc 1.16 (0.64-1.62) 0.95 53.1 1 0.10 0/4/16
nedc -0.15\(\lambda\) ned 1.28 (0.65-1.83) 0.90 35.0 2 0.25 0/2/18
nedc -0.15\(\lambda\) nedc 1.16 (0.71-1.83) 0.90 56.3 1 0.20 0/3/17
ned 0 ned / nedc median \(\hat\beta\) -0.00084 / -0.0029 — 74.4 / 57.3 1 / 3 FP 0.00 / 0.00 0/8/12, 0/15/5
nedc 0 ned / nedc median \(\hat\beta\) -0.0029 / -0.0048 — 124.1 / 80.5 1 / 1 FP 0.00 / 0.05 1/10/9, 0/14/6

On the same tree, the centred fit's AIC is lower than the raw fit's by a median 0.73 and 0.89 (raw-generated trees, -0.35 and -0.15\(\lambda\)) and 1.43 and 0.67 (centred-generated), and by +0.06 and -0.11 at zero (delta_c_vs_raw): the direction the hypothesis predicts, smaller than the 2 units that change a choice. No cell is sampler-limited; 75% to 95% of the fits at an effect ended on their clock, so the cells are clock-limited by the later convention.

E18 selection and recovery
Figure 1. Top: selection over dd by > 2 AIC for the raw (gold) and centred (purple) fit, on trees generated each way; at -0.15\(\lambda\) both stay at 0.05-0.25, below the dashed 0.5 of the rule. Bottom: median fitted over generating coefficient, 0.88 to 1.28 in every cell.
E18 recovery per tree
Figure 2. The fitted coefficient of every tree against its generating value, by generator (columns) and fitted model (rows); black diamonds are cell medians. The two fits spread alike at each effect.

Conclusion

Rule not met. Under the centred fit, selection at -0.15\(\lambda\) is 0.10 on raw-generated trees and 0.20 on centred-generated trees, not \(\ge 0.5\). Recovery is no worse (0.88-1.16 for nedc against 1.00-1.28 for ned), and false positives stay at 0 to 1 of 20. The centring moves AIC by under one unit in the predicted direction, so the difficulty at -0.15\(\lambda\) is power, not parametrisation, and nedc is an equivalent model, offered in the package but not the default. E18 measures only 100 tips, turnover 0.10, \(\rho\) 1 and negative effects; the centred covariate without an \(N\) term (edc) is measured in E24.

Its trees come from linear-link ned generators and the raw-ED simulator before f30a791, whose effect on these generators is not recorded, and its fits are unconditioned and unfinished; E46 measures recovery under the conditioned likelihood and E47 selection on a grid of effects (Estimability).